Moreland Road Clinic Osteopathy
0497 092 255
85 Moreland Road, Coburg VIC 3058
Book Online
OSTEOPATHY COBURG & OSTEOPATHY BRUSWICK - OSTEO IN COBURG & BRUNSWICK
  • About Us
    • What Is Osteopathy? >
      • History of Osteopathy
      • Osteopathic Principles
    • What do osteopaths treat? >
      • Ankle Sprain
      • Bursitis
      • Chronic Pain
      • Elbow Pain
      • Headaches
      • Heel/Arch Pain
      • Hip Pain
      • Knee Pain
      • Low Back Pain
      • Neck Pain
      • Pregnancy-related Issues
      • Sciatica and Nerve Pain
      • Scoliosis
      • Seniors and Age-Related Conditions
      • Shoulder Pain
      • Sports Injuries
      • TMJ (Jaw) Pain
      • Wrist & Hand Pain
    • Dr. Edmund Bruce-Gardner
  • Blog
  • Resources & Links
  • Contact
    • FAQ
  • About Us
    • What Is Osteopathy? >
      • History of Osteopathy
      • Osteopathic Principles
    • What do osteopaths treat? >
      • Ankle Sprain
      • Bursitis
      • Chronic Pain
      • Elbow Pain
      • Headaches
      • Heel/Arch Pain
      • Hip Pain
      • Knee Pain
      • Low Back Pain
      • Neck Pain
      • Pregnancy-related Issues
      • Sciatica and Nerve Pain
      • Scoliosis
      • Seniors and Age-Related Conditions
      • Shoulder Pain
      • Sports Injuries
      • TMJ (Jaw) Pain
      • Wrist & Hand Pain
    • Dr. Edmund Bruce-Gardner
  • Blog
  • Resources & Links
  • Contact
    • FAQ

MRCO BLOG

Medical Musings, Health Hypotheses & Therapeutic Thoughts

28/1/2018

0 Comments

The Trouble With Evidence-Based Practice... (Part I)

 
I find myself in a bit of a quandary.  In the years since I have graduated, our knowledge of the body, and the weird and wonderful ways it can go wrong, has changed dramatically.

One of the ways in which this is the case is our approach to the nature of pain and injury.

We have been moving away from the idea that "the issue is in the tissue" (i.e. you have a damaged [insert structure here] that is causing your pain), and more towards an understanding that, well, things are rarely that simple!  This puts more emphasis on 'command and control', and recognises that pain is multifactorial, that is, influenced by lots of different things.  This poses a problem for the study and treatment of these issues.

For example, there is a difference between an osteopathic technique, which is a particular intervention e.g. manipulation of the L4/5 spinal segment (part of your spine, in the low back area); and osteopathic treatment, which refers to the entire encounter with the osteopath, and will likely include many different techniques/approaches.  

As osteopathy is an 'holistic' discipline (it tries to treat the whole body/person rather than just the bit that hurts), you might treat someone with a painful/restricted L4/5 [region of the spine] with the aforementioned manipulative technique.  However, in patient A this is combined with work through the mid and upper back region, and in patient B, with the pelvis and legs.

Doing an experiment to find out how helpful that L4/5 manipulation is, then, does not take into account the effect of the work above (with Patient A) or below (with Patient B) the painful areas.

And even in the same patient, at various stages in treatment, different areas might be assessed as being more or less relevant.

When these studies are being done, they obviously want to make sure there is nothing else going on that might cause the pain, so will often use MRI or X-Ray (both ways of looking at what is going on inside the body) scans.  If there is nothing obviously causing the patient's symptoms, it will be lumped under the category 'non-specific low back pain'.  However, there will be lots of factors that are not the same between these patients - "always remember you're unique - just like everyone else!" - and thus the useful information we can get from these studies is even smaller.

HOWEVER, we do have quite a few studies from the last few decades that can tell us a little about how people get better after hurting themselves, and what helps (and doesn't!).

As an ethical osteopath, I obviously want to use the best methods to help my patients get back to their lives.  But the problem is, if I only go on the evidence, and only do things that are proven to work, I would not do much!  

This is because much of what we treat does not have a good evidence base.  This does not mean it does not work (millions of happy patients would argue otherwise!), but that the research is not there either way (for many reasons, some of which are described above).

So this blog post will end with one phrase familiar to any readers of scientific literature: "more research is required"; but with an addendum: "in the areas we can research effectively​"
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Subscribe to our mailing list

    * indicates required

    Authors

    Drs. Edmund Bruce-Gardner and Soraya Burrows are osteopaths

    Dr. Claire Ahern is a clinical psychologist 



    All practise in Melbourne, Australia

    Categories

    All
    Acupuncture
    Addiction
    Anatomy
    Anxiety
    Biomechanics
    Bursitis
    Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
    CBT
    Childbirth
    Chronic Pain
    Conditions
    Control
    Cramping
    Cricket
    Depression
    Diagnosis
    Dry Needling
    Dysfunction
    Evolution
    Exercise
    Exercises
    Fashion
    Frozen Shoulder
    Hand
    Headache
    How To Help
    Knee
    Low Back Pain
    Meme
    Mental Illness
    Mental Illness
    Mindfulness
    Obstetrics
    Occupational Issues
    Online
    Osteopath Near Me
    Osteopathy
    Pain
    Pain Management
    Patient Advice
    Patient Advice
    Patient Education
    Patient Experiences
    Pelvic Pain
    Pokemon
    Postpartum
    Pregnancy
    Psychology
    Reflections
    Research
    Rotator Cuff
    Sciatica
    Science
    Seaside
    Self Care
    Self-care
    Shoulder
    Simple Pleasures
    Smoking
    Sports
    Stretching
    Swimming
    Theory
    Training
    Travel
    Treatment Options
    Videos

    RSS Feed

Picture
Osteopathy at Moreland Road Clinic

High quality & personalised service from experienced professionals.

A safe, effective & collaborative approach to patient care.


All osteopaths undertake a 4-5 year university degree and are licensed and registered healthcare pracitioners.

Find Us
Moreland Road Clinic
85 Moreland Road
Coburg VIC 3058
P (03) 9384 0812 F (03) 9086 4194

osteopathy@morelandroadclinic.com.au
Popular Blog Posts

  • Telehealth for Osteopathy
  • Can You See your Osteopath During the Coronavirus Outbreak?
  • 9 ways to self-treat your headaches. Number 9 Will Shock You!
  • Pain During Pregnancy: An osteopathic perspective
  • Common causes of knee pain: Part III
  • Low Back pain: A look at the facts
  • 8 Stretches To Help Your Low Back Pain
  • A Common Source Of Wrist & Hand Pain: Carpal Tunnel Syndrome (CTS)
  • What is Chronic Pain?

    Contact Us If You Have Any Questions:

    Please tick if you would like to receive the clinic newsletter, normally emailed once per season (every 3 months or so)
Submit
Osteopathy at Moreland Road Clinic is on Moreland Road, near the corner of Nicholson Street/Holmes Street, on the border of Coburg, Brunswick & Thornbury.

This makes Osteopathy at Moreland Road Clinic the ideal location for people in the inner north and outer northern suburbs of Melbourne, including: Coburg, Coburg North, Coburg East, Brunswick, Brunswick East, Brunswick West, Fawkner, Oak Park, Glenroy, Preston, Pascoe Vale, Pascoe Vale South, Gowanbrae, Hadfield, Essendon, Moonee Ponds, Thornbury and Reservoir.