Moreland Road Clinic Osteopathy
0497 092 255
85 Moreland Road, Coburg VIC 3058
Book Online
OSTEOPATHY COBURG & OSTEOPATHY BRUSWICK - OSTEO IN COBURG & BRUNSWICK
  • About Us
    • What Is Osteopathy? >
      • History of Osteopathy
      • Osteopathic Principles
    • What do osteopaths treat? >
      • Ankle Sprain
      • Bursitis
      • Chronic Pain
      • Elbow Pain
      • Headaches
      • Heel/Arch Pain
      • Hip Pain
      • Knee Pain
      • Low Back Pain
      • Neck Pain
      • Pregnancy-related Issues
      • Sciatica and Nerve Pain
      • Scoliosis
      • Seniors and Age-Related Conditions
      • Shoulder Pain
      • Sports Injuries
      • TMJ (Jaw) Pain
      • Wrist & Hand Pain
    • Dr. Edmund Bruce-Gardner
  • Blog
  • Resources & Links
  • Contact
    • FAQ
  • About Us
    • What Is Osteopathy? >
      • History of Osteopathy
      • Osteopathic Principles
    • What do osteopaths treat? >
      • Ankle Sprain
      • Bursitis
      • Chronic Pain
      • Elbow Pain
      • Headaches
      • Heel/Arch Pain
      • Hip Pain
      • Knee Pain
      • Low Back Pain
      • Neck Pain
      • Pregnancy-related Issues
      • Sciatica and Nerve Pain
      • Scoliosis
      • Seniors and Age-Related Conditions
      • Shoulder Pain
      • Sports Injuries
      • TMJ (Jaw) Pain
      • Wrist & Hand Pain
    • Dr. Edmund Bruce-Gardner
  • Blog
  • Resources & Links
  • Contact
    • FAQ

MRCO BLOG

Medical Musings, Health Hypotheses & Therapeutic Thoughts

25/11/2019

0 Comments

Ten Things To Bear In Mind When Looking Up Health Information Online

 
by Dr. Edmund Bruce-Gardner
Picture
We live in a time of unprecedented access to information, with almost the sum knowledge of humanity seemingly only a few clicks away on the internet.
​
This is almost a problem, because with the huge amount of (often contradictory) information out there, how do you know who and what to trust?

The internet is a great leveller. No-one is ‘in charge’, and anyone can build a website.

If I decided I wanted to make a site explaining that Paul McCartney died in 1966 and was replaced by a lookalike, or that the earth is flat, there are no educational or professional qualifications required, and no rules or regulations that will stop me from doing so. 
​So you can’t automatically assume that anything you find on the internet is true [1].
So how can you assess the trustworthiness of a site giving you health information, assuming you don’t have a degree in medicine yourself?  We can use tools to help analyse information, regardless of what it is about.
​
Whatever you are reading, you can ask yourself questions about:
Who wrote this? Where? And Why?  Context is always key to understanding information.
We can use the ABC formula of evaluation:
A – ​


​
​B –
Authority (is the information from a credible source? i.e. Who provides it?)
Accuracy (does the site provide references to peer-reviewed scientific literature?)
Bias (who pays for the site? Remember, if the product is free, you’re the product! Are ads and sponsored content clearly labelled as such?)
Picture
C – ​
Comprehension (Is the information understandable? Is the site easy to navigate?)
Currency (are there dates on the material or pages?  Medical knowledge moves very rapidly, and if the material you are looking at is over three or four years old, it may well be out of date)
Using tools like these, even if we know nothing about the subject matter, we can assess likely bias and decide whether or not the website we are looking at is likely to help us find out about our search topic.
Picture
​The “About” or “About Us” section on websites is often a very good place to go to start answering these questions. It should tell you who is running the website, and why.  It may also tell you about the site’s contributors/writers. 
Also keep an eye out for a ‘Shop’ or ‘eStore’ button somewhere, this will give important indications as to the operators’ goals.
​It should always be clear who wrote the content, and whether it is accepted information (look for citations and references to the original data or peer-reviewed work), an opinion piece/blog, or an advertisement. 
What are some other points to keep in mind?
Some signs that you are on the wrong site(!):
Look at the general tone of the information. Is it too emotional?  Does it promote miracle cures?
No single treatment works for everyone, or for everything.  Two people with the same problem may need different treatments; and all conditions are different.
Don’t trust anyone who says that their ‘cure’ is 100%, all the time; or cures multiple different conditions. 
Picture
As a general rule, the old adage If it looks too good to be true, it probably is holds up; if the claims made are unbelievable, you probably shouldn’t believe them!
Picture
An appeal to authority is a type of logical fallacy that we humans are often prone to.   It's where we associate an argument with a well-known 'authority' who (and this is crucial) is not an authority on the topic at hand.

An example might be citing Albert Einstein as an authority on religion (ever hear 'his' quote "God does not play dice"??) when his primary expertise was actually in physics. 
​
A humorous take on this can be seen the in the "I am Arthur, King of the Britons" scene from Monty Python.

Just because Beyonce, Jim Carrey or Gwynneth Paltrow believe something about science or health, does not make it more likely to be true (unless they are talking about entertainment!).
Personal stories (anecdotes) are also not proof that something works. As the old quip goes, “The plural of ‘anecdote’ is not ‘anec-data’”.
As mentioned above, all conditions are different, and may have many different factors influencing them.   These influences and effects are very subtle, and can only be teased out by examining and comparing thousands of cases. 
Picture
Speaking ‘personally’, does the site want your personal information, like email address or date of birth? What for? What will they do with it? Look for their privacy policy if available.
Picture
"Mmmmmmm..... Natural arsenic...."
“Natural” does not always mean that something is safe (arsenic is natural. So is uranium, and gamma radiation!) or that it actually works.  
Picture
Tornados are also natural!
By the same token, “chemicals” is often thrown around like a it’s a bad thing.
​​Dihydrogen monoxide is a chemical. It’s also another way of saying water, which composes around 70% of our bodies. Everything is made of chemicals, and the study of how this all works is called chemistry.
It is entirely possible to misinform people while not saying anything technically untrue at all.  Have a look at this satirical website, expounding the dangers of dihydrogen monoxide.

It’s a major constituent of acid rain, accelerates corrosion and rusting of many metals, may cause severe burns, has been found in the excised tumours of terminal cancer patients, etc. etc.
Sounds scary, huh? 
Picture
Now, if you know that they are talking about water, you can see how everything mentioned on the page is true, but taken out of context and spun in such a way as to make it sound very scary indeed.
​
In fact, in 1997, Nathan Zohner, a fourteen year old student from Idaho Falls, as part of a science project gave 50 fellow students a paper called “Dihydrogen Monoxide: The Unrecognized Killer” [2].  He subsequently gathered 43 signatures calling for the ban of “DHMO”, six were undecided, and only one recognised that "DHMO" was in fact plain ol' water.
​Notably, the title of this science project was “How Gullible Are We?”.
​So, don’t be one of Nathan’s classmates. Read everything critically, and chase up any claims and sources found in the text.
Footnotes

​​[1] it’s funny that people seem to have forgotten that, because it was incessantly repeated to me, as a young internet user (I was in my teens in the nineties and early noughties), that I should “never trust anything you read online, always protect your real identity/details, oh and did I mention not trusting anything or anyone you come across on the internet?”

[2] Mikkelson, David (June 22, 1999). "Is Dihydrogen Monoxide Dangerous?". Snopes.com. Retrieved November 24, 2019.
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Subscribe to our mailing list

    * indicates required

    Authors

    Drs. Edmund Bruce-Gardner and Soraya Burrows are osteopaths

    Dr. Claire Ahern is a clinical psychologist 



    All practise in Melbourne, Australia

    Categories

    All
    Acupuncture
    Addiction
    Anatomy
    Anxiety
    Biomechanics
    Bursitis
    Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
    CBT
    Childbirth
    Chronic Pain
    Conditions
    Control
    Cramping
    Cricket
    Depression
    Diagnosis
    Dry Needling
    Dysfunction
    Evolution
    Exercise
    Exercises
    Fashion
    Frozen Shoulder
    Hand
    Headache
    How To Help
    Knee
    Low Back Pain
    Meme
    Mental Illness
    Mental Illness
    Mindfulness
    Obstetrics
    Occupational Issues
    Online
    Osteopath Near Me
    Osteopathy
    Pain
    Pain Management
    Patient Advice
    Patient Advice
    Patient Education
    Patient Experiences
    Pelvic Pain
    Pokemon
    Postpartum
    Pregnancy
    Psychology
    Reflections
    Research
    Rotator Cuff
    Sciatica
    Science
    Seaside
    Self Care
    Self-care
    Shoulder
    Simple Pleasures
    Smoking
    Sports
    Stretching
    Swimming
    Theory
    Training
    Travel
    Treatment Options
    Videos

    RSS Feed

Picture
Osteopathy at Moreland Road Clinic

High quality & personalised service from experienced professionals.

A safe, effective & collaborative approach to patient care.


All osteopaths undertake a 4-5 year university degree and are licensed and registered healthcare pracitioners.

Find Us
Moreland Road Clinic
85 Moreland Road
Coburg VIC 3058
P (03) 9384 0812 F (03) 9086 4194

osteopathy@morelandroadclinic.com.au
Popular Blog Posts

  • Telehealth for Osteopathy
  • Can You See your Osteopath During the Coronavirus Outbreak?
  • 9 ways to self-treat your headaches. Number 9 Will Shock You!
  • Pain During Pregnancy: An osteopathic perspective
  • Common causes of knee pain: Part III
  • Low Back pain: A look at the facts
  • 8 Stretches To Help Your Low Back Pain
  • A Common Source Of Wrist & Hand Pain: Carpal Tunnel Syndrome (CTS)
  • What is Chronic Pain?

    Contact Us If You Have Any Questions:

    Please tick if you would like to receive the clinic newsletter, normally emailed once per season (every 3 months or so)
Submit
Osteopathy at Moreland Road Clinic is on Moreland Road, near the corner of Nicholson Street/Holmes Street, on the border of Coburg, Brunswick & Thornbury.

This makes Osteopathy at Moreland Road Clinic the ideal location for people in the inner north and outer northern suburbs of Melbourne, including: Coburg, Coburg North, Coburg East, Brunswick, Brunswick East, Brunswick West, Fawkner, Oak Park, Glenroy, Preston, Pascoe Vale, Pascoe Vale South, Gowanbrae, Hadfield, Essendon, Moonee Ponds, Thornbury and Reservoir.